Expert Commentary

She Said Yes. She Meant No. What a Physician Learned When His Mother Became the Patient

When Altamash Raja, DO, RMSK, CSCS sat beside his mother after her heart attack, the gaps he had never noticed from his own exam room became impossible to ignore.

Published October 30, 2026
She Said Yes. She Meant No. What a Physician Learned When His Mother Became the Patient
Dr. Altamash Raja, DO, RMSK, CSCS
As told to MedStory News
Dr. Altamash Raja, DO, RMSK, CSCS
PM&R and Sports Medicine
View Profile
Advertisement
Website Design

The representative had finished his instructions. He asked Raja's mother if she understood how to use the wearable defibrillator vest she was about to take home. She said yes. Raja, sitting beside her in the hospital room, turned and asked her the same question in their shared language. She looked at him and said no. "She almost went home with a device meant to save her life that she didn't know how to use," Raja said. "What surprised me was how easily 'yes' passes for understanding, and that no one would have caught it if I hadn't been there."

That moment, unremarkable to everyone else in the room, reoriented something for Raja. Physicians routinely ask patients whether they understand their care instructions. Patients routinely say yes. It is a transaction that can feel complete while the actual transfer of information never happens, and the consequences, missed doses, misused equipment, delayed calls for help, fall entirely on the patient.

Raja changed his practice. He stopped asking "Do you understand?" and started asking patients to explain the plan back to him in their own words: how they would take a medication, what they would do at home, when to call. "When English isn't their first language, I use an interpreter or bring in the family member they trust, even when it takes longer," he said. "If a patient can't explain the plan back to me, I haven't explained it well enough." The burden, in his telling, belongs to the physician, not the patient who nodded along.

His mother's care delivered a second lesson, this one about the administrative machinery that surrounds treatment and that most patients have no map for. Her medication, running nearly $4,000 a month, was denied because a specialty pharmacy had an outdated insurance ID on file. What followed was months of back-and-forth before Raja spent four hours on a single phone call, moderating between the pharmacy and the insurer, to get the claim resolved. "I know this system and it still took that much," he said. "Most families don't. Their treatment waits while they fight, or they're left with a bill that can be catastrophic."

For a physician trained to identify and address problems, the experience of being unable to simply fix things for someone he loved was its own kind of clinical education. The system he works inside every day looked entirely different from a chair beside a hospital bed, and the view from that chair is the one most of his patients occupy alone.

Advertisement
Patient Education Portal