The results came back after the weekend. The patient, a close friend, had already been discharged. George Naum had admitted him twice before for blood clots in his extremities, both times resolving with treatment. The CT scan ordered during the second admission told a different story: a pancreatic tumor. Naum chose to wait before making the call. When he finally sat down with his friend and his wife, they were overcome with grief. The man died a month later. "I still remember that helpless feeling nearly 30 years later," Naum wrote, adding a small emoji that somehow made the sentence heavier, not lighter.
That story threads through almost everything Naum has to say about delivering devastating diagnoses. The feeling he describes is not guilt in the clinical sense, not a failure of procedure or protocol. It is something more fundamental: the collision between what physicians are trained to do and what, in those moments, cannot be done. "I felt like I had let them down," he said, "and totally against how we as physicians are trained to 'fix' things." The training prepares physicians to intervene. It has far less to say about what happens when intervention is no longer the point.
Naum describes himself as a "glass half full" type, a disposition that shaped how he handled ominous diagnoses for much of his career. He acknowledges the tension plainly: "Sometimes in not wanting to destroy hope, false hope can be created and I may have been guilty of that on occasion. Idealism too often is not realism." He is careful to say he still leans toward optimism, but that years of experience have pushed him toward a more pragmatic approach to those conversations. The instinct to protect a patient from despair is not wrong, he suggests. What shifts is the physician's willingness to let reality assert itself even when it is unwelcome.
"I think patients and families don't perceive the immense emotional toll it takes on a physician to have to deliver such devastating news. For me, it was very traumatic, in some cases bordering on PTSD because of the helplessness I felt."
That word, helplessness, appears more than once in how Naum talks about this part of his work. It points to something the broader conversation about physician well-being often softens or reframes. The distress is real and specific: it is not simply the burden of a difficult job but the experience of standing in front of someone whose life has just changed and having nothing adequate to offer. Naum credits his faith with carrying him through many of those situations. It is a personal answer to a structural absence, one physician finding his own footing on ground the profession never quite taught him to stand on.
Patients, as the Context framing for this piece observes, often remember the exact words they heard. What they rarely know is how unprepared the person saying them may have been, and what those words cost the physician long after the room emptied out.
